I had a similar problem with Oblivion, but then I realized I was playing Elder Scrolls wrong (because that's apparently a thing). I enjoyed the game when I found out that the game doesn't want you to follow the story, it wants you to screw around with self-defined goals. » 10/06/14 1:57pm 10/06/14 1:57pm

I did the same thing. I played my decisions as Malcom Reynolds as I could, i.e. making terrible but ultimately decisive choices involving the world while ultimately taking care of my crew. How that turned out is straight renegade for ME1, mostly renegade for ME2, and right in the middle for ME3. » 9/17/14 12:43pm 9/17/14 12:43pm